Disapointed with Trion

[emseebee]

If it's true then that is indeed a piss poor result.

[Snowflakes]

This is really messed up.

[BladeDancer]

Answers Trion, Answers.
Where are they.

[Iranicus]

Answers Trion, Answers.
Where are they.

See above, Someone proved he is a troll.

[Korkhan]

See above, Someone proved he is a troll.

Not sure we are reading the same thread. Op himself said in first post he had know they had the same name as a bigger guild, so to avoid them, they had chosen other server. And the linked thread just confirmed his version - he tried to avoid the bigger guild.

[Kaedan]

Seriously? Sorry but I don't see this other Guild defending themselves one bit.
So I tend to believe the OP.

And let me add that 100 vs 5 people doesn't matter.
Trion should have let the 100 people go back to what-ever game
they came from.

There is no middle ground. It's either right, or wrong. And this,
as posted on here, is most definatly WRONG.

We can pull an Egypt and march on Trion

Nothing is ever black and white. There is always grey area. And sense of right and wrong, good and evil, those are all relative. You do not know all the circumstances and you don't even know if what info has been given to us is true... so you really can't make a fair judgement.

Assuming that he's telling the truth, it would be nice to understand the GMs reasoning. But really, this is a trivial thing. He chose a horrible guild name with a horrible reputation behind it. He also got refunded his plat, so he's not out A SINGLE thing, IMO. In fact, I would thank the GM for giving me a chance to change my guild's name to something that didn't suck.

[Kaedan]

Yup. Case closed. He stole the name on purpose and got what was coming to him.

lol Ha! I knew it.

[omfgitsfrag]

That's really ****ing outrageous.

[omfgitsfrag]

That's really ****ing outrageous.

Just read he's a troll.

NM

Trion, sort out the editing policy.

[telete]

First come, first served. If you got the name first, you should not have been disbanded whether you stole it or had it for 2 decades.

Lame on Trion's part if true.

totally agree. Do they have the copyright of the name? No? So like grasamo said, first come, first served.

[Herculeet]

Yeah, he just "happened" to name his lil' guild to the one guild pretty much everyone knows.

Never heard of them.

[Mogway]

Regardless of if he "stole" the name or not it should be first come first serve.

If the facts are the smaller guild made the name first, regardless of intentions with the name then they should keep the name. Does it suck for the bigger guild? Absolutly. However life isnt fair and neither are games. That said the same idea applies to the smaller guild. Life isnt fair and neither are games.

[BBommarito]

Looking at the servers forums, I am guessing Goon Squad.

Goon Squad, there is a blast from the past.

If it's the same Goon Squad I know, they (The one I know of) are...idiots to put it politely. Granted, I had much fun killing them for many, many years.

[Rinkitink]

Why are you raging over something you clearly no nothing about? Do you really think you know more then the people that handle the servers?

You mean do we know more than some low paid customer service rep? Absofrickinlutely.

[Rinkitink]

Two points:

If you took Goon Squad, that's pretty blatantly copying their name. That's a fairly infamous guild name. And not generally for good reasons.

But... since when do guilds trademark their guild name? Many guild names are replicated and re-used. If they wanted the guild name on that server, they should've rolled there first and gotten it.