That reward doesn't need to be gear with superior stats. If better players are given better gear, you run the risk of creating a hierarchy where people who are truly better lose because they're undergeared.Right now, pvp is bland and has no respect. Every day I listen to people mock it because of how pointless it is. This new bracket will turn that around and give a reward that shows just how good the player is because it will not be a cake walk to earn.
If they're that amazing, why would their team of P40s lose?Wins, losses are not exactly a good match making stat, there are plenty of players that are amazing players even on losing teams.
Another way would be to make the system solo queue only, faction nonspecific, so it tracks player strength instead of group or faction strength.. . .Premades only is about the only way to effectively rate a person's PvP potential without creating a huge, convoluted, easily spoofable system for rating people, especially in this type of game.