So hopefully I can shed some light on this topic. 51 Purifier is absolutely terrible. The reason it became so FotM was because of Greenscale healing early on. Everyone said it was the tank healing spec, and it was. The [B][I]only[B][I] reason it was good is because of the healing debuff (75% less healing) from Greenscale on the breathe. Damage mitigation >>>>>>>>>>> Healing when a healing debuff is involved (also in general). So the shields from Puri reigned supreme. Also this was back when all of the T2 gear was stacked with SP and less stats, and had almost no crit on any T2 items.
I have NO idea why people even mention Herald and 51 Purifier. Herald has a breathe....but that was never the point of the 51 Purifier, the healing debuff was. 51 Purifier is actually terrible for Herald healing, if for whatever reason the MT gets debuffed you don't have a Healer's Covenant to negate the debuff with and keep him alive.
34 Purifier and 32 Sent is more than capable in the current gear levels of being used for Greenscale, I would actually use it over 51 Purifier. It is actually way more healing also. When you sit at 30-35% crit on RF's in T2 gear that is a lot of 1.5 casts. The 51 Purifier RF shield only shields for an extra ~400 with high gear levels. The amount of shields you get on him will be about the same with all of the Serendipity procs you will get, with that extra healing from that extra RF.
Please, please, understand 51 Purifier is absolutely terrible.




Bookmarks